Home Appraisal fees
Countywide, Landsafe and KB Homes Named in Appraisal Scheme Lawsuits
A lawsuit that was filed on October 30th, in the U.S. District Court of Florida, has named both Countrywide, including its subsidiary Landsafe, and KB Homes as defendants in a class action suit. The suit details “alleged predatory practices in an attempt to dominate mortgage lending and corrupt the loan underwriting and approval process”.
Two different schemes are mentioned, inflated appraisals and inflated appraisal fees.
Scheme #1 – Inflated Appraisals
In this first scheme, Countrywide and Landsafe, which is an appraisal management company owned by Countrywide, inflated the value of KB Homes so the values would always be equal to or more than the contracted sales price of the properties.
Scheme #2 – Inflated Appraisal Fee
Countrywide and Landsafe worked together to receive fees from appraisers for a set price and would then turn around and charge the buyers sometimes up to double the cost of the original appraisal.
Countrywide requires that the property be appraised through its subsidiary, Landsafe.
Landsafe hires out to individual appraisers willing to meet their demands.
Both companies reap the benefits, as they both come from a single parent company, and values can be influenced.
If appraisers did not adhere to the demands of countrywide regarding value “matching”, the appraiser would be black-listed from performing any other Countrywide loans
Landsafe dictates appraisal fees to the appraisers, which the independent appraisers agree to.
When the consumer sees the final cost breakdown, the appraisal fees are highly inflated, sometimes at almost double the cost of the actual appraisal.
For Landsafe’s accounting purposes, there is no breakdown of fees listed. It only states the appraiser fee and then “a fee for no services rendered”.
In order to conceal the scheme, appraisers are ordered by Landsafe and/or Countrywide not to include any paperwork, including invoices, with the submitted appraisal indicating the fee charged for the services rendered. In this way, it stops the paper trail and further conceals the scheme from outsiders.
Why does the scheme work?
- There is no one to question Countrywide and Landsafe, as they are owned by the same company.
- There is no communication between the consumer and the appraiser,
- There is no paper trail to follow.
Are there more situations just like this one? Absolutely. Will they all get caught? Probably not.
What does this mean for the appraiser?
While much of the blame for this situation was placed on the lender and appraisal management company, you cannot discount the fact that some appraisers were meeting demands when the lenders were asking for inflated numbers or contracted sales price matching in their values.
In the appraisers quest to have the HVCC rules reversed or suspended for 18 months, this definitely puts a damper on it. While the suit focuses on the lender, the politicians will be looking at how to control the appraisers. Their assumption will be that if the appraiser acted as an unbiased third party, none of this would have happened.
About the Author
For a complete list of AMC’s go to www.amc300.com
Are these lender fees reasonable on a 91,000 home loan?
1% Origination Fee = $913.50
Appraisal Fee = $350
Credit Report = $14.51
Tax Related Service Fee = $125
Processing Fee = $195
Underwriting = $300
Wire Transfer = $25
Application = $295
Flood Cert. Fee = $20
Admin. Fee = $180
Transaction Fee = $329
Doc Prep Fee = $200
Located in New Orleans, LA.
The appraisal and credit are about right. Tax service is usually between $75 and $100, but I don’t know where you are. Fees can be very different across the country.
There are a few junk fees there…processing AND underwriting AND application AND administration AND transaction AND doc prep…Are all of those from the lender or could some be from the title company? They seem a little high if they’re all for the lender. I’ve worked for several different lenders over the years, and I’ve never seen that many lenders fees…is there a mortgage broker? That could account for some of the fees.
Do you know there are lenders that pay the closing fees for you? I don’t mean roll them into the loan, but actually pay them.
Expenses & Fees You Can Expect When Buying a Home
School impact fees postponed
The West Hawaii School Impact Fee District, scheduled to go into effect this month, has been postponed — with an unknown future implementation date — likely because the county has refused to participate.
In a perfect world, you have to have willing buyer and a willing seller. Neither is under duress. home appraisal fees Both are in a position to maximize gain and are trying to do this. But in the real world, things are rarely that simple and equally balanced. home appraisal fees Which is why people feel differently about the appraisal value of a house.